Gordon Stokes Transport  

Transport in Environmental Impact Assessments

Transport Home Photography Home  

Last updated - Jan 2013

Pages in this series

1 - Transport Assessment Introduction

2 - Trip generation

3 - Routes taken by traffic

4 - Pass by, diverted and other trips

5 - Other aspects

6 - Transport in Environmental Statements

Environmental Impact Assessments - Summary

Transport is treated diferently in Environmental Impact Assessments and Environmental Statements. While TAs are concerned with the resulting level of traffic and how it will affect junctions, EIAs are more concerned with the percentage increase in traffic on particular roads. EIAs also, as the name suggests, look at other aspects of traffic as well as congestion.

When is an EIA or ES needed?

Large proposed developments may require an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA or EA) with an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS or ES). The EIA or EA is the overall process, i.e. screening, preparation of a report, consultation on the report, decision-making, and monitoring if appropriate, while the EIS or ES is the actual report. In the EU they're lebelled EIA and EIS, but for some reason in the UK they’re often referred to as EA and ES. And the terminology is used quite loosely. Now that's all cleared up we can move on!

The overall assessment is carried out according to quite strict guidance, and developers should put in a formal 'screening request' to the Local Planning Authority to see whether there is deemed to be a need for one, prior to putting in a planning application.

The EIA should be done before a planning application, and should include various alternatives for the development, with the idea that the least environmentally damaging option should generally be chosen. This is not always the case - sometimes it is only when a Planning Authority sees the scale of a development that they suggest that a screening application is required.

EIAs cover many other aspects as well as transport, including air pollution, noise, visual intrusion, and social and economic factors. And the issues to be looked at under transport overlap with some of these. Most EIAs are enormous documents, not for the faint hearted.

Transport Assessment compared to EIA

A TA is concerned with traffic increase and congestion – it aim (in the eyes of developers, assuming that no one objects to a plan on traffic grounds) is to provide a basis for agreeing mitigation payments (S106 payment). It is concerned with traffic prediction across the local area. The transport part of an EIA's transport component is concerned with wider impacts of transport changes. It considers pollution, noise and others (listed below). While TA analysis needs to look at all traffic changes, EIAs only look at links in the road network where traffic is forecast to increase above certain percentages (see below). A TA is generally concerned with 'traffic levels in peak traffic conditions' while an EIA is concerned with 'the impacts that occurs when the proposed development will have maximum effect'.
(More to follow)

Very Draft from here onwards

Guidance can be found at ...

What guidance exists on Transport aspects?

There is no getting away from the fact that the guidance for EIAs with respect to transport is old. Guidance is contained in ...
Guidance Notes No. 1. Guidelines for the Environmental Assessment of Road Traffic. The Institute of Environmental Assessment, March 1993 (IEA, March 1993)
... which was written by a panel of experts, based on their assessment of available research at the time.

When should transport issues be considered?

Assuming that an EIA is needed, the guidance suggests two rules should be followed.

  • Rule 1: include highway links where traffic flows will increase by more than 30% (or the number of heavy goods vehicles will increase by more than 30%);

  • Rule 2: include any other specifically sensitive areas where traffic flows have increased by 10% or more.

Two points are important:

Sensitive areas are not especially sensitive environmentally, but relate to people and areas sensitive to traffic and actually will include most built up areas. As most TIAs are for things like quarries, power stations etc they are less common in urban area. The guidance says:
Para 2.5 “… useful to identify particular groups or locations which may be sensitive to changes in traffic conditions. The following checklist …. But others could be added if the assessor considers it appropriate.”

  • People at Home
  • People in Workplaces
  • Sensitive Groups including Children, Elderly and Disabled
  • Sensitive Locations e.g. Hospitals, Churches, Schools and Historic Buildings
  • People Walking
  • People Cycling
  • Open Space, Recreational Sites and Shopping Areas
  • Sites of Ecological/Nature Conservation value
  • Sites of Tourist/Visitor Attraction

Increase in traffic is treated differently than in TAs. While TAs look at increases for peak hours in terms of traffic on the roads without the development, in EIAs we are concerned with when the development will have maximum impact. So if a supermarket only added 5% to a very busy rush hour this would not be important. But if the peak shopping hour, say 12-1pm, added 40% to the otherwise much quieter roads that would trigger a need for assessment, even in a 'non sensitive' area.

What needs to be considered

A large number of topics need to be considered, but many of these overlap other areas of the EIA, so text on some aspects (in the transport section) may be short.

  • Noise
  • Vibration
  • Visual effects
  • Severance
  • Driver delay
  • Pedestrian Delay
  • Pedestrian amenity
  • Fear and intimidation
  • Accidents and safety
  • Hazardous loads
  • Air pollution
  • Dust and dirt
  • Ecological impact
  • Heritage and conservation issues
  • (Effects on agriculture and disruption due to construction not considered, although they are in most other aspects of the EIA)

The areas not dealt with elsewhere in the EIA so with more said about them under transport should include severance, driver and pedestrian delay, amenity, fear and intimidation, accidents and safety and hazardous loads. Air pollution, noise and vibration, dust and dirt may or may not have much included depending on construction needed and use by HGVs etc.

It’s not all straightforward - e.g. Severance guidance

Severance refers to the division of a community when separated by a major traffic artery. It can include difficulty of crossing road, or physical barrier of the road.

But the guidance is somewhat contradictory saying that it can relate to quite minor flows if they impede access to essential facilities. But later it says "Changes in traffic flow of 30%, 60% and 90% are regarded as producing 'slight', 'moderate' and 'substantial' changes in severance". Given that it is likely to affect 'sensitive groups and areas' where 10% is the threshold for consideration it seems odd that such high levels of traffic increase are needed to trigger 'severance change'. I asked one of the original authors and he pointed to literature being sparse on the topic when they wrote the guidance, and saying he thought there hadn't been much research since then.

The guidance also says that it can be applied to residents, motorists or pedestrians (and cyclists). Assessors should consider road width, traffic flow and composition, traffic speeds, availability of crossing facilities, and numbers of movements affected. It points out that the old and young are more sensitive. It suggests that assessors should define facilities for which access is potentially impaired, facility catchment areas and populations in areas – as total, and vulnerable groups

How bad is bad? - examples of scaling

Different EIAs use different 'formulae' to assess how bad the impacts will be. Some use a single scale of impacts from, say, 'negligible' to 'major', while other use a two dimensional matrix comparing the effect with the numbers of people or 'sensitive recepors' affected. (More to follow)

Conclusions

Guidance is very specific on some points but not on others. Use of % increase – masks difference between 30% on quiet residential road, as against an already virtually gridlocked busy area. There is a large amount of leeway in assessing impacts, and readers should not take what is written as 'proven'. (more to follow)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_assessment has a section on the EU use of EIAs




Back to Transport Index

Gordon Stokes, 2013