Gordon Stokes Transport  

Routes taken by traffic - Trip distribution

Transport Home Photography Home  

Last updated - March 2015

Pages in this series

1 - Transport Assessment Introduction

2 - Trip generation

3 - Routes taken by traffic

4 - Pass by, diverted and other trips

5 - Other aspects

6 - Transport in Environmental Statements

Routes to the site - summary

For a larger development it's important to know which routes traffic will use to approach the site. This section describes how complex an analysis might need to be and looks at various ways in which it might be treated.

Where will vehicles come from?

The main concern of a TA in terms of where traffic comes from and goes to is how it will affect traffic levels on local roads and junctions, but only as far as that traffic will have any measurable impact. So for a small development on a road that's not busy it would just really be at the site entrance, but for a major development the impacts could stretch some distance.

For larger developments it's important to know from which areas people will come to use it. Some assessments assume that traffic will arrive in proportion to how much traffic uses roads in the locality. But for something such as a major new shopping centre, or a leisure centre then its 'catchment' area is important, as well as whether people are more likely to come from one area than another. This could be very complex; for example an opera house and a theme park would probably attract people from different types of area. A multi screen cinema is unlikely to attract people from an area where there's one already showing the same films, while might attract more from where there is no cinema at all.

Simple cases

For a smallish development the proportion of traffic that is likely to turn in from the left or right (and how it leaves the site) is of most importance. In many cases it's a no brainer. On a dead end street nearly all will head away from the dead end! And more journeys will be towards a local centre nearby than a road on which there is very little for 10 miles. For housing this might be best estimated by where local people tend to work and shop. Some use proportions of people in the area currently who work in different areas, and make assumptions about the roads they use. But local shopping centres, schools etc are also important.

More complicated cases

Issues can be complex due to scale of the development, and/ or the local road layout. A large development on a single road outside an urban area may be more straightforward than a medium sized one in a suburban area where the road network is dense, and where there are different routes choices possible from the same area.

Some TAs will simply 'assign' traffic in proportion to what is already on the local road network "in proportion to surveyed turning counts" (or similar jargon). This is, at best, the easiest thing to do when it's not really known where traffic will come from, or at worst, an attempt to even out the traffic increases so that no local junction is seen to take a larger than average share that would cause congestion.

Modelling journey origins - Gravity Models

For large developments such as shopping centres there may be a need to use data sources such as population censuses and survey data, and to model likely origins of journeys using, for example, a gravity model.

A Gravity Model uses the same logic as for planetary attraction. For bodies in space the attraction between them (gravity) is measured by the mass of each body divided by the square of the distance between them. So if the distance doubles then the attraction is lessened by a factor of "2 times 2" (4). Very close big things attract much more than very distant small ones.

This idea was applied to transport modelling in the 1960s with some success to predict traffic flows between zones with different populations and numbers of jobs or other facilities. But it was found that the "square" was not realistic so had to be altered in the light of what is observed. A 'power of 1.4' or similar was generally found to be more realistic (but this figure varies from place to place).

Some TAs will use a modified gravity model, though since a full transport model requires an enormous amount of work, most will just use a 'distance decay function' that assumes that people will come in proportion to a 'power' of the distance. (More people per 1000 population will come from a nearby area than would from 3 miles away). This may be OK, but if a 'power of 2' ('squared') is used, it will almost certainly exagerate the proportion who come from close by, and will therefore tend to show fewer people using the main roads to reach the site than the local roads.
I once reviewed a TA which implied that avery man, woman and child living within about 1/2 a mile of a proposed supermarket would drive there every day - but very few would drive from further away!

Estimating journey origins - other methods

Just about any method can be used to predict where people will come from. Some will use common sense, but other methods such as retail models may be used (for shopping developments), or analyses of the likely origins for office employees with specialist skills. As a general rule of thumb this is never going to be more accurate than anything that can be explained in simple plain english - if it's more complicated there may be reasonable suspicion of wool being pulled over eyes.

Routes used from journey origins

Most consultants these days will use internet mapping and directions to show journey times and routes from different areas. There are a few things to watch out for:-

  • Journey times will be different at different times of day, and the quickest route may vary
  • Origin 'zones' may not reflect a single logical route to a site. A large zone may cover an area from which people might use a variety of routes. Sometimes it is assumed all from a zone will use the quickest route, but sometimes trips will be split in proportion to how many they think will use one route or another
  • Most TAs are written by people living a long distance away with little or no local knowledge. They often ignore well known local rat runs.

The next page is concerned with 'pass-by' and 'diverted' trips

Back to Transport Index

Gordon Stokes, 2015